Hiring processThreat landscapePublished Mateusz Smoczyński

Won't fake candidates get caught at contract signing?

Most fake candidates pass contract signing. What W-2, 1099, corp-to-corp and agency hires really check, what the scheme is after, and what helps earlier.

Key takeaways
  • At contract signing you verify the paperwork. The paperwork belongs to a real person. Someone else does the work.
  • W-2, 1099, corp-to-corp and agency hires all check documents. None of them checks who is on the camera.
  • Renting out an identity is common: in an October 2026 survey, 33% of employed US adults had heard of or knew someone paid to do it.
  • Once inside, the end game is the paycheck, your data, direct theft or extortion.
  • The later you find out, the more you've already paid. The cheapest place to look is the application.

After every talk I give about fake candidates, someone asks the same question. Usually it’s a person who is new to the topic, and it’s a fair one.

“Okay, they fake the CV and the interview. But at some point they have to sign a contract. Give their name, their tax number, their bank account. Won’t it all fall apart right there?”

Short answer: usually not. The paperwork checks out. That’s exactly why the scheme works.

The one we hired

In 2024 my agency placed a remote developer who wasn’t who he said he was. I told the full story in What is a fake candidate? Here is the part that matters for contracts.

He worked through a one-person business, which is how many tech contractors in Europe work. The business was registered. The name on the passport matched the CV. Nobody noticed the passport had expired years earlier. The client shipped a laptop to his address.

The identity belonged to a real person. It just wasn’t his. A front person had the laptop, and someone else connected to it remotely and did the work.

What gave him away was his behavior. His commits kept landing between 2 and 4 in the morning. Only then did anyone go back to the paperwork and ask him to join a video call. The man on the screen was not the man in the passport.

His contract was clean. His commit history gave him away.

What the contract stage actually checks

In the US the setup depends on how you hire. Here’s what each route verifies, and what it misses.

How you hire What gets checked What it misses
W-2 employee Form I-9, often E-Verify, a background check These confirm the details belong to a real person with the right to work. Since August 2023, E-Verify employers can inspect I-9 documents remotely over live video. A stolen or rented identity passes, and the background check comes back clean, because the real person is clean.
1099 contractor A W-9 with an SSN or EIN No I-9 at all. Payment goes to whatever account is on file.
Corp-to-corp The company’s details You sign with a company. In one 2025 case, operators set up shell LLCs, 21 fake websites and 29 bank accounts to look legitimate.
Staffing agency or vendor Whatever the agency checked The FBI warns that companies outsourcing IT work are more exposed, because they’re removed from the hiring itself.
The laptop A US shipping address The laptop lands in a “laptop farm” in the US and gets operated remotely from abroad. The IP address looks local.
What the contract stage checks and what it misses. W-2 employee: Form I-9, often E-Verify and a background check; a real, clean identity passes and neither shows whose face is on the camera. 1099 contractor: a W-9 with an SSN or EIN; no I-9 at all and pay goes to the account on file. Corp-to-corp: the company's details; you sign with a company, not a person. Staffing agency: whatever the agency checked; you are one step removed from the hiring. The laptop: a US shipping address; a laptop farm operated from abroad, the IP looks local.
Every route checks documents. None of them checks who is doing the work.

My own practice looks similar. For one enterprise client we run a full background check through an employer of record. For most remote contracts the check is a personal data form. For a contractor’s business we confirm it’s registered. Nobody sees a document live.

Renting out an identity is more common than it sounds. In a survey of 1,500 employed US adults published in October 2026, 33% said they had heard of or knew someone who was paid to let another person use their identity or work authorization.

At contract signing you verify the paperwork. The paperwork belongs to a real person. Someone else does the work.

So what’s the end game?

If the paperwork passes, the fraud can run for months. The cases from the last two years show four outcomes.

1. The paycheck. Christina Chapman ran a laptop farm from her home in Arizona. North Korean IT workers used 68 stolen or bought identities of US citizens to get jobs at 309 US companies. Paychecks went into her accounts and then abroad. The scheme brought in more than $17 million. The real owners of those identities got tax bills for jobs they never had. She was sentenced to 102 months in 2025.

2. Access to data. In June 2025 the DOJ searched 29 suspected laptop farms in 16 states. More than 100 companies had hired these workers, using the identities of more than 80 US citizens. At one defense contractor, data on military technology covered by ITAR export rules was accessed and taken.

3. Direct theft. In the same case, a worker at a blockchain company changed smart contracts and enabled the theft of about $740,000 in crypto.

4. Extortion. In January 2025 the FBI warned that once these workers are discovered and fired, some hold stolen source code and data hostage and demand a ransom. Some publish the code.

And sometimes the damage starts on day one. In 2024 a security company hired a remote engineer who passed a background check, reference checks and four video interviews. He used a real, stolen US identity with a photo touched up by AI. Malware showed up on his company laptop on his first day.

Which fake candidates would the contract even catch?

Not every fake candidate hides who they are. The way I see it, there are four types:

  • State-backed operators, like the North Korean IT workers, working under a full assumed identity.
  • Laptop farms, running many jobs at once on expired, bought or stolen identities.
  • The “ChatGPT candidate”, a real person with a CV inflated by AI.
  • The fraudulent candidate, a real person with real experience who manipulates the ATS, for example with hidden text or prompt injection.

The contract stage can, in theory, catch the first two, and only when the identity is invented. When it’s stolen or rented, the documents are real. The last two are real people with real documents. The contract will never flag them.

By the time someone reaches the contract, your recruiter has screened them, your hiring manager has interviewed them, you’ve made an offer and maybe shipped a laptop. Finding out then is the most expensive way to find out.

The cost of finding out late, stage by stage. 1, application: a few minutes of reading, the cheapest place to look. 2, screening: a recruiter call. 3, interviews: hours of senior engineers and managers. 4, offer: checks, a contract, a hiring decision. 5, laptop: equipment shipped. 6, access: your code, data and systems.
Each step adds cost. The contract sits near the end.

The later you find a fake candidate, the more you've already paid for them.

What actually helps

Look at the application. Most fakes leave traces long before the contract: a CV whose file “Author” field shows a different name, a VoIP number instead of a mobile, an email address that doesn’t match the name, a LinkedIn profile created last month. That’s where we built TalentShield to look, inside the ATS, before anyone books an interview.

See the person live with the document, before access. Do it before the laptop ships and before accounts go live. The FBI goes further and suggests doing as much of the hiring in person as you can.

Watch the first weeks. Working hours that don’t fit the time zone, logins from several places at once, data moving to personal accounts. In my case, the commit times were the tell.

Make it a shared job. In many companies nobody owns this. In my view, TA and People Ops have to own it together, with Security in the loop. TA sees the candidate. People Ops sees the paperwork. Neither sees the full picture alone.

If you’re weighing where background checks and ID verification fit in all this, read Background checks and ID verification come too late.

The bottom line

The contract stage feels like a safety net. For most fake candidates it isn’t one. The paperwork is real. The person is the question. The earlier you ask it, the cheaper the answer.

Book a demo and see what turns up in your own pipeline before the next offer goes out.

Free checklist · 8 pages · PDFWho checks what at each hiring stageSix stages from the first application to day one, the checks that matter at each one, and who owns them.Get the free checklist
See it in your ATSTalentShield runs candidate fraud detection inside Greenhouse, Teamtailor, Lever and any ATS with an API. Book a demo or talk to Mateusz.

Questions people ask

Won't a fake candidate get caught when they sign the contract?

Usually not. The contract stage checks paperwork, and in most schemes the paperwork belongs to a real person whose identity was stolen, bought or rented. The documents are real. The person doing the work is someone else.

Does Form I-9 or E-Verify stop fake candidates?

They confirm that the details belong to a real person with the right to work in the US. They don't confirm that the person on the camera is that person. Since August 2023, E-Verify employers can inspect I-9 documents remotely over live video, so a stolen or rented identity can pass.

Are contractors and corp-to-corp hires more exposed?

Often, yes. A 1099 contractor fills in a W-9 and no I-9 at all. In a corp-to-corp setup you sign with a company, not a person. The FBI also warns that companies outsourcing IT work are more exposed, because they are removed from the hiring itself.

What do fake candidates want once they're hired?

In the cases from the last two years: the paycheck, access to data, direct theft (for example crypto), and extortion after they are discovered, when stolen code and data are held for ransom. Sometimes malware shows up on day one.

Where is the cheapest place to catch a fake candidate?

At the application, before anyone books an interview. Most fake applications leave traces in the file, the CV, the contact details and the online profile. Then see the person live with the document before laptops ship and accounts go live, and keep an eye on the first weeks.

Sources

  1. US Department of Justice, July 2025: Arizona woman sentenced for $17M IT worker fraud scheme that generated revenue for North Korea
  2. BleepingComputer, June 2025: US disrupts North Korean IT worker laptop farm scheme in 16 states
  3. FBI IC3, January 2025: North Korean IT workers conducting data extortion (I-012325-PSA)
  4. FBI IC3, May 2024: North Korean IT workers using US-based facilitators
  5. Mayer Brown, August 2023: remote Form I-9 verification (alternative procedure)
  6. The Register, July 2024: KnowBe4 hired a fake North Korean IT worker
  7. GCheck, October 2026: Verified Entry announcement and survey of 1,500 employed US adults
  8. Team Up / TalentShield, hiring experience (2024 to 2026) · internal

Keep reading

Hiring process14 October 2026

Background checks and ID verification come too late. Here's what goes first.

Background checks and ID checks catch fake candidates late, after the interviews. What it costs, why moving IDV first hurts hiring, and what goes first.

Read →
Hiring process6 November 2026

Fake candidates are an agency problem first

Recruitment agencies face fake candidates earlier and pay more for them. What it costs an agency, what to check before you submit a CV, and how to make vetting part of your offer.

Read →

See it on your own pipeline.

Leave your email and the ATS you use. We come back within one business day to book a 30-minute demo, on your own applicants if you want. Just have questions? Talk to Mateusz, 30 minutes, no slides.

Book a demo